   | Citation | Abstract |
|---|
|
Bartley III, William Warren. (1990). Unfathomed Knowledge: Unmeasured Wealth: On Universities and the Wealth of Nations. La Salle, IL: Open University Press.
| This book is divided into four parts. The prologue outlines the basic freedoms that enable the developments of civilization. The first part discusses the impact of the ‘unfathomable’ nature of knowledge on the arts and sciences. The second part continues themes in the first part, and argues that the institutions on which we rely most for the production of knowledge are not organized in such a way as readily to advance knowledge. The third part provides a case study to apply Bartley’s contentions. |
|
Birdsall, Nancy (1996). Public Spending on Higher Education in Developing Countries: Too Much or Too Little? Economics of Education Review, 15(4), 407-19.
| Birdsall discusses problems with reallocating public resources for education in developing countries from higher to lower education levels. Birdsall argues that there is a case for maintaining and even increasing higher education spending as long as public funds can be directed to research and other ‘public good’ functions. Birdsall speculates that the true social rate of return to certain higher education components is high. |
|
Bloom, David E. (2005). Raising the Pressure: Globalization and the Need for Higher Education Reform. In Glen A. Jones, Patricia L. McCarney, and Michael L. Skolnik (Eds.), Creating Knowledge, Strengthening Nations: The Changing Role of Higher Education. Toronto/Buffalo/London: University of Toronto Press.
| Bloom argues that globalization is exerting new pressures on higher education that both magnify the benefits of higher education reform and reduce its costs. Universities must now respond to market needs to strengthen capacity and contribute to regional/national economic development. His argument rests on three points: (1) that higher education is essential to promoting economic growth and sustainable human development; (2) in a globalizing world, devoting more resources to higher education must be given higher priority; and (3) implementation of higher education reform requires deeper attention. Bloom focuses on the technical and political aspects of system-level reform. |
|
Blundell, Richard, Lorraine Dearden, Alissa Goodman, and Howard Reed (2000). The Returns to Higher Education in Britain: Evidence from a British Cohort. The Economic Journal, 110, 82-99.
| The authors use birth cohort panel data to examine the impact that degree level qualifications and other higher education qualifications have on the earnings of individuals in the medium to longer term. They compare the outcomes of those degree holders with individuals who had the prospect of undertaking higher education but chose not to. Their approach involves matching these individuals according to observed characteristics such as ability, family background, and demographics, and then comparing outcomes between individuals who pursued higher education and otherwise identical individuals who had the opportunity but did not. |
|
Blundell, Richard, Lorraine Dearden, Costas Meghir, and Barbara Sianesi (1999). Human Capital Investment: The Returns from Education and Training to the Individual, the Firm and the Economy. Fiscal Studies, 20(1), 1-23.
| This paper reviews evidence on the returns to education and training for the individual, the firm, and the economy. It begins by evaluating the empirical work on the topic, focusing on the recent literature that has attempted to control for potential bias in the estimated returns from human capital investments to employers. The authors conclude that a lack of suitable data and methodological difficulties have resulted in a paucity of empirical studies. The final part of the review tries to assess the contribution of human capital to national economic growth at the macroeconomic level (which generally involves ‘new growth’ theories). |
|
Brint, Steven (2005). Creating the Future: ‘New Directions in American Research Universities’. Minerva, 43(1), 27-52.
| Brint assesses the causes and consequences of recent American efforts to configure the research university as an engine of economic and social change. Drawing upon interviews and strategic plans, the paper describes recent policies to encourage ‘interdisciplinary creativity’, in a context of increasing income from private gifts and endowments. |
|
Burtless, Gary, and Roger G. Noll (1998). Students and Research Universities. In Roger G. Noll (Ed.), Challenges to Research Universities. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press.
| Burtless and Noll review evidence on the value to students of receiving a higher education at a research university. There is a surprisingly little amount of research on this topic, and almost all that exists does not distinguish between the varieties of universities. The authors review data on tuition costs and the evidence surrounding the earnings premium to higher education, and then summarize the sparse information relating to research universities. |
|
Bynner, John, Peter Dolton, Leon Feinstein, Gerry Makepeace, Lars Malmberg, and Laura Woods (2003). Revisiting the Benefits of Higher Education. London: Higher Education Funding Council.
| This report studies two cohorts of graduates, born in 1958 and 1970. It considers the labor market benefits of higher education. The risk of unemployment was significantly lower for men and women with higher education qualifications than for those with other qualifications including A-levels and lower. Graduates were found to exhibit greater levels of multi-skilling than other groups, and were more likely to put their computer skills to work. |
|
Bynner, John, Tom Schuller, and Leon Fienstein (2003). Wider Benefits of Higher Education: Skills, Higher Education and Civic Engagement. Zeitschrift fur Padagogik, 48(3), 341-61.
| The authors examine a theoretical framework of research organized by human, social, and identity capital. The work is based on two large-scale longitudinal datasets. The authors focus of four outcome clusters: (1) health; (2) well-being; (3) social attitudes; and (4) political involvement. The paper concludes that education is an absolute prerequisite for promotion of personal well being and a cohesive society. |
|
Carnoy, Martin (1987). Higher Education and Graduate Employment in India: A Summary of Three Case Studies, IIEP Research Report No. 64. Paris: UNESCO.
| The relationship between higher education and the economy in India, the labor market for college graduates, and the role of the public sector in reducing unemployment among college graduates is assessed in three studies. For each of the geographic locations, attention is directed to: educational expenditures as a percentage of state domestic product, expenditures on education at current and constant prices; graduate employment and unemployment rates; distribution of employed and unemployed graduates by family income; graduates' number of months/years for first regular job, by subject studies; and earnings of university graduates by subject of study (for Bombay and Karnataka universities). In addition to the study findings, the theoretical background to the research is described, with attention to theories of higher education and society and theories of education and labor markets. |
|
Castanos-Lomnitz, Heriberta, Axel Didriksson, and Janice Newson (1998). Reshaping the Educational Agendas of Mexican Universities: The Impact of NAFTA. In Jan Currie and Janice Newson (Eds.), Universities and Globalization: Critical Perspectives. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
| The authors provide a two-edged account of Mexico’s inability to reap the anticipated benefits of its inclusion in NAFTA. One edge of the account stresses the ways that Mexico’s system of higher education is handicapped relative to its trading partners for taking up the new order of business required of it by NAFTA. On the other edge of the story, politics and history rather than economics assume primary roles. Using a case study of the Universidad Autonoma Nacional de Mexico, the chapter builds on historical documents and interviews with business leaders, academics, and government officials on the new requirements for universities to collaborate with industry to support economic integration. |
|
Cohen, Wesley, Richard Florida, Lucien Randazzese, and John Walsh (1998). Industry and the Academy: Uneasy Partners in the Cause of Technological Advance. In Roger G. Noll (Ed.), Challenges to Research Universities. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press.
| The authors draw on two research projects: the first examines university-industry R&D centers in the United States, while the second considers the impact of university R&D on industrial R&D for the U.S. manufacturing sector. The authors conclude that universities contribute greatly to industrial R&D, that ties between universities and industry have grown, and that industry support in academic research is bringing greater restrictions on the disclosure of the results of university R&D. |
|
Cohen, Wesley, Richard Nelson, and John Walsh (2002). Links and Impacts: The Influence of Public Research on Industrial R&D. Management Science, 48(1), 1-23.
| Nelson and Walsh use data from the Carnegie Mellon Survey on industrial R&D to evaluate, for the U.S. manufacturing sector, the influence of ‘public’ (i.e., university and government R&D lab) research on industrial R&D, the role of that public research plays in industrial R&D, and the pathways through which that effect is exercised. They find that public research is critical to industrial R&D in a small number of industries and importantly affects industrial R&D across much of the manufacturing sector. Contrary to the notion that university research largely generates new ideas for industrial R&D projects, the survey responses demonstrate that public research both suggests new R&D projects and contributes to the completion of existing projects in roughly equal measure overall. |
|
Ehrenberg, Ronald G. (2003). Financing Higher Education Institutions in the 21st Century. New York: Andrew W. Mellon Foundation.
| Ehrenberg discusses the growing resource imbalance that is emerging between public and private institutions of higher education, and the growing inequality of resources that is occurring within the public and private sectors. He illustrates implications of some of these changes for patterns of faculty compensation and faculty turnover observed across academic institutions. Ehrenberg suggests that although institutions are increasingly generating revenue to support their research through the commercialization of faculty members’ research findings, very few institutions are generating substantial funding from commercialization activities. Ehrenberg concludes with speculations about the directions in which the U.S. higher education system will evolve over the new few decades and discusses potentially major financial issues facing academic institutions in the future. |
|
Florax, Raymond, and Henk Folmer (1992). Knowledge Impacts of Universities on Industry: An Aggregate Simultaneous Investment Model. Journal of Regional Science, 32(4).
| This paper is concerned with the impacts of academic knowledge production on the investment behavior of the manufacturing industry. Within this model, the knowledge impacts of universities are represented by a diffusion function, which accounts for the possibilities of contagious and hierarchical diffusion of knowledge. The main result of the case study relating to the Netherlands is that academic knowledge production has a significant positive impact on investments in equipment which is strongest in the neighborhood of central places (i.e., following a hierarchical diffusion pattern). |
|
Glomm, Gerhard and B. Ravikumar (1992). Public vs. Private Investment in Human Capital: Endogenous Growth and Income Inequality. Journal of Political Economy, 100, 818-834.
| Glomm and Ravikumar present an overlapping generation model with heterogeneous agents in which human capital investment through formal schooling is the engine of growth. They use simple functional forms for preferences, technologies, and income distribution to highlight the distinction between economies with public education and those with private education. They find that income inequality declines more quickly under public education. On the other hand, private education yields greater per capita incomes unless the initial income inequality is sufficiently high. Also, societies will choose public education if a majority of agents have incomes below average. |
|
Goldstein, Harvey, Gunther Maier, and Michael Luger (1995). The University as an Instrument for Economic and Business Development: U.S. and European Comparison. In David D. Dill and Barbara Sporn (Eds.), Emerging Patterns of Social Demand and University Reform: Through a Glass Darkly. Oxford/New York/Tokyo: Pergamon Press.
| The authors explore the principal means by which the universities have an economic impact on their regions, and weigh the relative merits of contemporary approaches to stimulating development. The authors conclude that universities face a broader and more complex set of demands, and whether a university should become involved in a particular set of activities depends both on the university structure and its region and economy. |
|
Gottlieb, Esther E., and Michael Chen (1995). The Visible and Invisible Crisis in Israeli Higher Education. Higher Education, 30, 153-173.
| Gottlieb and Chen focus on the Israeli experience of developing higher education as part of the expansion of a nation-building economic project. They draw on inferences in research for insight into visible and invisible sources; on the break in equilibrium in the Israeli academy; on the conflation of the missions of teaching and research; and on the disciplinary relevance of research. |
|
Green, Madeleine, Peter Eckel, and Andris Barblan (2002). The Brave New (and Smaller) World of Higher Education: A Transatlantic View. Washington, DC: American Council on Education.
| This paper outlines the impact of globalization, competition, and resource restrictions on higher education, and advocates for a long-term, holistic view of university responses to these impacts. Such a perspective is necessary for institutions to determine the ‘fundamental mental values’ of higher education; consider how higher education can serve a function beyond career preparation; find accessible ways of demonstrating the benefits of higher education; consider how the university best serves the state as a partner, consumer, and regulator; and consider how institutions become agile and adapt to changing environments. |
|
Maani, Sholeh (1996). Private and Social Rates to Secondary and Higher Education in New Zealand: Evidence from the 1991 Census. Australian Economic Review, 113, 82-100.
| With significant increases in the demand for higher education in New Zealand since the 1980s, the question of the size of the returns to investments in education has been of significant interest. Despite this interest, there have been few studies based on aggregated measures. This study utilizes micro-level data from the 1991 New Zealand Census, and employs and compares the conventional methods of regression earnings functions, and internal rate of return analyses of private and social rates of return. The results indicate that returns to education are economically significant, at rates that are higher for females. |
|
Mauch, James E. (2000). The Impact of Higher Education on Emerging Markets. In Matthew S. McMullen, James E. Mauch, and Bob Donnorummo (Eds.), The Emerging Markets and Higher Education: Development and Sustainability. London: Falmer Press.
| Mauch applies his experience studying higher education administration in a number of countries to the interface of higher education and emerging market societies. He takes a broad and integrative approach, raising a number of issues that need to be addressed to fully understand the complexity of the relationship between education and emerging market countries seeking to achieve sustainable growth. |
|
Morote, Elsa-Sofia, and John L. Yeager (2000). Higher Education: The Social, Political, and Economic Driver of Mexico’s Future. In Matthew S. McMullen, James E. Mauch, and Bob Donnorummo (Eds.), The Emerging Markets and Higher Education: Development and Sustainability. London: Falmer Press.
| Morote and Yeager argue that in the 20th century Mexican higher education has had a modest impact on the country’s economic growth. Since the 1980s, there have been important changes in higher education in terms of availability and quality. These changes reflect the efforts of the different stakeholders (government, universities and the private sector) to work together to bridge the gap between what industry needs and what it receives from the higher education system. |
|
Nelson, Richard R. (2004). The Challenge of Building an Effective Innovation System for Catch-Up. Oxford Development Studies, 32(3), 256-74.
| Catching up is not a process of exact copying but reflects deliberative and often creative modifications to tailor practice to national conditions, especially those practices associated with institutions and norms within the physical technologies embodied in productive economic activities and their operation are embedded. These ‘social technologies’ are more difficult to acquire than the physical. This paper demonstrates these propositions by looking historically at changes in legal, research, and training institutions. It concludes by questioning the extent to which current practices of extensive patenting and licensing of U.S. universities have been the key to their effectiveness in contributing to economic development and the relevance of copying such practices in the broad institutional context of other nations. |
|
Neville, Warwick (1998). Restructuring Tertiary Education in Malaysia: The Nature and Implications of Policy Changes. Higher Education Policy, 11(4), 257-81.
| The Malaysian Government is implementing policies aimed at a major restructuring of tertiary education throughout the country. The stimulus for change derives from the needs of rapid economic development, and in particular a demand for a skilled and well-educated professional labor force, a long-established shortfall in the number of domestic places available in higher education, and a desire to raise participation rates. Measures include corporatization of the universities in the public sector and active encouragement of state-owned enterprises and private corporations to establish universities in the private sector. While such changes represent a radical departure from the structure of the earlier system, retention of principles favoring such measures as affirmative action for student places and entry requirements for the majority bumiputera and promotion of Bahasa Malaysia as the predominant medium of instruction is likely to limit the effectiveness of the anticipated revolution in higher education which the Government proclaims this to be. |
|
Nowotny, Helga (1995). Mass Higher Education and Social Mobility: A Tenuous Link. In David D. Dill and Barbara Sporn (Eds.), Emerging Patterns of Social Demand and University Reform: Through a Glass Darkly. Oxford/New York/Tokyo: Pergamon Press.
| Nowotny assess the feasibility of expectations regarding the university as an agent to lessen economic disparities, given what is known of the impact of these policies over time in various countries. Nowotny advocates for a transdisciplinary education that includes the ability to prepare for teamwork and collaborative problem definition; an openness within regional and global frameworks towards other cultures; and an escape from provincialism. |
|
Park, Namgi (2000). Higher Education in a Rapidly Developing Country: The Case of the Republic of Korea. In Matthew S. McMullen, James E. Mauch, and Bob Donnorummo (Eds.), The Emerging Markets and Higher Education: Development and Sustainability. London: Falmer Press.
| Park describes the development of higher education in South Korea in relation to the country’s economic development. This analysis is concerned with the development of educational policy and shows the direction that Korea is preparing to go. Included is also a discussion of the impact of the national economic crisis on higher education. |
|
Peters, Michael A. (2003). Classical Political Economy and the Role of Universities in the New Knowledge Economy. Globalisation, Societies, and Education, 1(2).
| Peters focuses on the economic importance of higher education as a key component of the knowledge economy. It discusses the genealogy and contributing strands to the newly emerging discourse and considers universities in the knowledge-driven economy by reference to the UK White Paper ‘Our Competitive Future’. It also considers the arguments advanced by Joseph Stiglitz for the ‘analytics of the knowledge economy’ and discusses universities in terms of ‘knowledge cultures’. Finally, Peters critiques of the policy discourse the knowledge economy as a basis of the new challenges facing universities under knowledge capitalism. |
|
Porter, Michael E. (1990). The Competitive Advantage of Nations. New York: Free Press.
| Porter sets out to understand the national attributes that foster competitive advantage in particular industries and presents education and training as the single greatest long-term leverage point available to all levels of government in upgrading industry. Porter identifies the following characteristics as essential for any state education program: (1) educational standards are higher; (2) teaching is a prestigious and valued professions; (3) the majority of students receive education and training with some practical orientation; (4) there are respected and high-quality forms of higher education besides the university; (5) there is a close connection between educational institutions and employers; (6) firms invest heavily in ongoing in-house training through industry associations or individually; and (7) immigration policies allow the movement of personnel with specialized skills. |
|
Rosenberg, Nathan and Richard R. Nelson (1994). American Universities and Technical Advance in Industry. Research Policy, 23(3), 323-348.
| There has been an intensification of interest in how universities can play a more effective role in promoting technical advance in American industry. However, very little of the discussion is solidly based on an informed analysis of the roles universities actually play today or the historical circumstances that caused universities to assume these roles. |
|
Ruberti, Antonio (2001). The Role and Position of Research and Doctoral Training in the European Union. In Jeroen Huisman, Peter Maassen, and Guy Neave (Eds.), Higher Education and the Nation State: The International Dimension of Higher Education, Oxford: IAU/Pergamon Press.
| Ruberti discusses the role and position of research in the European Union. Science and cooperation have expanded enormously, and as the place of scientific and technological cooperation assumes further dimensions, those involved will be forced to consider how research in these areas will be organized. Ruberti stresses the need for an articulated balance between basic and finalized research, and for a policy entailing the convergence of national research efforts and increased cooperation. With respect to Ph.D. education, creating a European dimension would strengthen the potential for both cooperation and collaboration. |
|
Ryoo, Jai-Kyung, Young-Sook Nam and Martin Carnoy (1993). Changing Rates of Return to Education Over Time: A Korean Case Study. Economics of Education Review, 12(1), 71-80.
| The accepted wisdom is that rates of return to lower levels of schooling are higher than to a university education and tend to stay higher even as a country develops. But increasing evidence suggests that there are many exceptions to this rule, especially during sustained periods of rapid industrialization. This paper examines changes in the rates of return in South Korea in the 1970s and 1980s. It shows that during this period the pay-off to lower levels of schooling fell substantially in absolute terms and relative to investing in completed 4-year college education, leaving college rates considerably above primary and secondary. The main restriction on students pursuing further education in such situations may therefore not be self-selection based on declining pay-off to further investment, but rather imposed selection, either through highly imperfect capital markets, or restriction on the number of places available in 4-year colleges. |
|
Salmi, Jamil (2003). Constructing Knowledge Societies: New Challenges for Tertiary Education. In Gilles Breton and Michel Lambert (Eds.), Universities and Globalization: Private Linkages, Public Trust. Paris: UNESCO.
| Salmi, representing the World Bank, reveals a major reversal of a trend. Having maintained that higher education was not a priority for developing countries and its funding should be confined solely to the beneficiaries of such education, the World Bank now calls into questions its former analyses and places higher education at the very center of its priorities. Moreover, it clearly demonstrates the degree of correlation between higher education and the economic development of emerging countries. |
|
Schoenberger, Alain M. (2005). Are Higher Education and Academic Research a Public Good or a Public Responsibility? A Review of the Economic Literature. In Luc Weber and Sjur Bergan (Eds.), The Public Responsibility for Higher Education and Research. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
| Schoenberger provides an overview of the existing economic literature as well as the available empirical data with regard to efficiency in academic research and higher education policy. Schoenberger concludes that the ability to economically measure the non-economic contributions of higher education are weak, and the consensus around the role of higher education as service to society is more likely to be achieved through political and policy debate. He also argues that faith in the market and its potential role in reforming the provision of higher education is based on a fundamental tenet of market ideology, but there is little evidence to support this efficiency effect. |
|
Schutte, Frits (1999). The University-Industry Relations of an Entrepreneurial University: The Case of the University of Twente. Higher Education in Europe, 24(1), 47-65.
| Schutte describes the development of the University of Twente from a regional teaching university into a national research university known as the ‘entrepreneurial university’ of the Netherlands. It begins by describing the actual position of the University of Twente and then follows with a brief description of the major developments of the last decades. The university has taken specific measures to increase its economic and social impact in its region through spin-offs from the university, an incubator in a Business and Science Park, and the generation of venture capital. The article estimates the regional impact of such activities and describes international activities. Finally, it explains the so-called entrepreneurial activities of the university. |
|
Slaughter, Sheila (1998). Federal Policy and Supply-Side Institutional Resource Allocation at Public Research Universities. The Review of Higher Education, 21(3), 209-244.
| Slaughter argues that higher education student aid policy and academic science and technology policy have undergone a sea change. During the past twenty years, higher education policy has shifted from being a policy arena in its own right; shifting from the arena described by Wolanin and Gladieux (1975), and gravitating towards Guy Neave’s (1988) analysis of higher education in the European Community, where higher education is ‘less a part of social policy…and is increasingly viewed as a subsector of economic policy. |
|
Subotzky, George (2005). The Contribution of Higher Education to Reconstructing South African Society: Opportunities, Challenges, and Cautionary Tales. In Glen A. Jones, Patricia L. McCarney, and Michael L. Skolnik (Eds.), Creating Knowledge, Strengthening Nations: The Changing Role of Higher Education. Toronto/Buffalo/London: University of Toronto Press.
| Subotzky argues that higher education is to be understood as advancing not only economic growth and entrepreneurialism, but also strategic societal goals of equity and redistributive justice. During the 1990s South African universities were to have played a crucial role in building a new society and in contributing towards the national development priorities of the new democracy. Subotzky contends that this policy position has been constrained by the ‘hegemony of the global, market-oriented, neo-liberal discourse’ and that the dominance of the single market model in South Africa has produced its higher education equivalent – the entrepreneurial university. |
|
Tornatzky, Louis G., Paul G. Waugaman, and Denis O. Gray (2002). Innovation U: New University Roles in a Knowledge Economy. Research Triangle, NC: Southern Growth Policies Board.
| The authors detail the best practices and cultures of twelve major research universities that are leading the way in promoting technology-oriented economic development in their states and communities (Georgia Tech, N.C. State University, Ohio State University, Penn State, Purdue, Texas A&M, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Virginia Tech, University of California-San Diego, University of Utah, Carnegie Mellon University, and Stanford University). The case studies look at external partnerships, including industry research partnerships, technology transfer, industrial extension and technical assistance, entrepreneurial development, industry education/training partnerships, and career services and placement. The studies also consider the institution’s enablers, and formal partnerships with economic development organizations and university/industry advisory boards and councils. |
|
Van Der Wende, Marijk (2001). The International Dimension in National Higher Education Policies: What Has Changed in Europe in the Last Five Eears? European Journal of Education, 36(4), 431-441.
| This article reviews two questions. First, whether the international dimension has indeed become more important in national education policy in the last five years, and if so, why? And second, whether the identified trend of growing economic interests related to internationalization goals has, in fact, persisted, and why? Answered using evidence gathered in the final evaluation of the SOCRATES I program, the article shows that whereas the SOCRATES program has had a very limited impact on system-level change, the Bologna Declaration has been a major push for the recognition and integration of the international dimension in national higher education policy. |
|
Wolf, Alison. (2002). Does Education Matter? Myths About Education and Economic Growth, London: Penguin.
| Wolf argues that high private returns to education are not matched by high or consistent social returns, and that even if some education has a positive impact, this cannot be extrapolated endlessly as education expands. Her argument may be summarized as follows: (1) education contributes to economic growth and productivity, but beyond a threshold its contribution is small and uncertain; (2) basic skills and general education are of greater economic value than vocational skills; (3) labor market selectors use education primarily as an indicator of general potential; (4) as education expands qualifications lose their labor-market value in absolute terms, but not relative to lower-level qualifications or no qualifications; (5) expansion and academic drift are the products of rational decisions on the part of young people; (6) the expansion of education has not reduced social inequalities in participation; (7) there is no substantial under-investment in training by British employers; (8) government interventions in vocational training are at best wasteful and usually harmful; and (9) the development of mass higher education reduces the sector’s potential to make an economic contribution through research or teaching. |
|
Wolfe, David A. (2005). The Role of Universities in Regional Development for Research Policy, and Action. In Glen A. Jones, Patricia L. McCarney, and Michael L. Skolnik (Eds.), Creating Knowledge, Strengthening Nations: The Changing Role of Higher Education. Toronto/Buffalo/London: University of Toronto Press.
| Wolfe critically examines how universities contribute to economic growth specifically in regional economic clusters. He suggests that universities perform two vital functions: as generators of new knowledge through their leading-edge research activities and as trainers of highly qualified labor. Both of these, when integrally linked, provide the essential infrastructure from which regional economic clusters can develop. Wolfe demonstrates why spatial proximity matters in a knowledge-based economy. He argues that it is a mistake to view the primary purpose of universities as spinning off research results into new products and firms. While this can assist in the growth of cluster development, this transformation of research findings into commercial products is too narrow a focus for universities and the research and teaching functions of universities remain essential. |
|
World Bank Group (2002). Constructing Knowledge Societies: New Challenges for Tertiary Education.
| This report describes how tertiary education contributes to building up a country ' s capacity for participation in an increasingly knowledge-based world economy and investigates policy options for tertiary education that have the potential to enhance economic growth and reduce poverty. It examines the following questions: What is the importance of tertiary education for economic and social development? How should developing and transition countries position themselves to take full advantage of the potential contribution of tertiary education? How can the World Bank and other development agencies assist in this process? |
|
Castells, Manuel (1994). The University System: Engine of Development in the New World Economy. In Jamil Salmi and Adriaan M. Verspoor (Eds.), Revitalizing Higher Education. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
| Castells works from the premise that no country can afford to be completely out of touch with the international system. He emphasizes the central role of universities in building endogenous technological capabilities that are critical at a time when development in increasingly driven by technology. Castells views international and regional cooperation as essential, but adds that to be successful regional programs or centers of excellence must be anchored in strong national universities. Building quality institutions will require selectivity in public support for advanced research and instruction, regional cooperation, innovation in delivery modes, increased use of modern instructional technology and complementing public subsidies with private contributions. |
|
Carnoy, Martin (1994). Universities, Technological Change, and Training in the Information Age. In Jamil Salmi and Adriaan M. Verspoor (Eds.), Revitalizing Higher Education. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
| Carnoy, reviewing evidence from five developing countries, argues that quality systems effectively manage the interaction between science, technology, economy, and society. Building national capacities to manage science and technology will, however, require establishing close linkages between universities, research centers in the country and abroad, the production sector and macro-economic policies. Such linkages can be expected to enhance the performance of individual institutions. |
|
Mansfield, Edwin (1994). Economic Returns from Investments in Research and Training. In Jamil Salmi and Adriaan M. Verspoor (Eds.), Revitalizing Higher Education. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
| Mansfield reviews the evidence on the contribution of higher education to economic growth and development and finds high social returns to investments in new industrial technology in developing countries, based to a significant extent on recent academic research. The benefits associated with investment in higher education are significant, but can only be realized in systems that give priority to the systematic pursuit of quality research and teaching. The demands of development will require an emphasis on the often neglected functions of higher education: the generation of scientific knowledge and technological know-how and the training of highly skilled manpower for all sectors of the economy. |
|
Brown, Phillip (1999). Globalisation and the Political Economy of High Skills. Journal of Education and Work, 12(3), 233-251.
| Brown develops a methodology for the comparative study of the political economy of skill formation with a particular focus on policies designed to develop routes to a high skills economy. It is argued that the advanced economies face a series of ‘pressure points’ in common which can only be addressed by making a series of policy trade-offs. But while the pressure points are common to these economies the trade-offs will be determined by the politics, culture and history of a nation’s economy and social development.
|
|
Arocena, Rodrigo and Judith Sutz (2005). Latin American Universities: From an Original Revolution to an Uncertain Transition. Higher Education, 50(4), 573-592.
| Arocena and Sutz discuss the prospects of Latin American public universities. They assert that universities could become an important actor in the development of Latin America, but prevailing trends point in a different direction. They focus on the interactions between specific traditions and social contexts on one hand, and global trends concerning the role of knowledge and academic changes on the other hand. Similarities and differences between developed countries and Latin America concerning current trends in higher education are analyzed and particular attention is paid to the interactions between what is happening in Latin American universities and the new insertion of the continent in the global economy.
|
| Lockett, Andy and Mike Wright (2005). Resources, Capabilities, Risk Capital and the Creation of University Spin-out Companies. Research Policy, 34(7), 1043-1057. | Lockett and Wright assess the impact of university resources and routines/capabilities on the creation of spin-out companies. They find that the number of spin-out companies created and the number of spin-out companies created with equity investment are significantly positively associated with expenditure on intellectual property protection, the business development capabilities of technology transfer offices and the royalty regime of the university. Their results highlight the importance not just of resource stocks, but also of developing appropriate capabilities of technology transfer officers in spinning-out companies.
|
| Hegde, Deepak (2005). Public and Private Universities: Unequal Sources of Regional Innovation? Economic Development Quarterly, 19(4), 373-386. | Hegde examines the geographic distribution of university patent citations during the years 1975 to 2000 to test if public university research spillovers are more likely to be localized at the state level as compared to those of private universities. Hegde finds little evidence of this hypothesis – regression estimates suggest that public university knowledge flows are not more likely to be captured within their state boundaries (compared to that of private universities). Hedge explains this finding by pointing to two distinct sets of factors: 1) a high-quality invention enhances the prospect of its local use by increasing the chances of its overall use and private universities outperform public universities in generating high-quality inventions; and 2) inefficiencies in the system of public universities work against the successful diffusion and localization of their research spillovers. |
| Black, Dan, Kermit Daniel and Jeffrey Smith (2005). College Quality and Wages in the United States. German Economic Review, 6(3), 415-43. | The authors estimate the effects of the quality of the college a student attends on their later earnings using data from a cohort of U.S. college students from the late 1970s and early 1980s. They find economically important earnings effects of college quality for men and women, as well as effects on educational attainment, spousal earnings and other demographic variables. These effects remain roughly constant over time and result primarily from effects on wages, rather than from effects on hours or labor force participation. They find that, over the lower part of the range of college quality, increases in college quality pass a simple social cost-benefit test. |
| Odagiri, Hiroyuki (1999). University-Industry Collaboration in Japan: Facts and Interpretations. In Lewis M. Branscomb, Fumio Kodama, and Richard Florida (Eds.), University-Industry Linkages in Japan and the United States. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. | Odagiri considers the diversity of university-industry collaborations in Japan and proposes that the form of such collaborations is embedded in Japanese social, economic, and institutional factors of the period. Odagiri first discusses the early stage of Japan’s development when universities were key players in industrial and technological development and then considers the current collaborations and government policies. Odagiri discusses the Exploratory Research for Advanced Technology (ERATO) program and the Fifth-Generation Computer Project is some detail. |
| Fogarty, Michael S. and Amit K. Sinha (1999). Why Older Regions Can’t Generalize from Route 128 and Silicon Valley: University-Industry Relationships and Regional Innovation Systems. In Lewis M. Branscomb, Fumio Kodama, and Richard Florida (Eds.), University-Industry Linkages in Japan and the United States. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. | Fogarty and Sinha examine Cleveland, Ohio in the context of the regional innovation system, focusing on the tension around national, state, and local objectives for encouraging university-industry relationships. They conclude that older industrial regions need a new framework for evaluating policy choices and considering investments in science and technology. State and local areas can more successfully capture economic benefits locally if they 1) clarify objectives, especially as they relate to the geography of spillover benefits; 2) invest strategically by building the strongest university-industry paths from basic research to local industry; and 3) develop a new local science and technology management system to ensure the integrity of the system. The authors develop a policy framework and conclude with suggestions as to how older U.S. industrial regions can develop appropriate university-industry structures. |
| Candell, Amy B. and Adam B. Jaffe (1999). The Regional Economic Impact of Public Research Funding: A Case Study of Massachusetts. In Lewis M. Branscomb, Fumio Kodama, and Richard Florida (Eds.), University-Industry Linkages in Japan and the United States. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. | Candell and Jaffe bring together different forms of empirical knowledge relating to the long-run economic effects of research activities and explore their implications in the context of a quantitative model of regional economic development. They provide a quantitative overview of the Massachusetts innovation system and present the results of an exercise in which existing empirical evidence about these linkages is combined with a regional economic model in order to estimate the consequences of changes in federal research funding. The authors identify three leverage points at which the contribution of science and technology to economic growth within a state or region can be increased: 1) via increases in the scale of research in the nonprofit or industrial sectors; 2) by enhancing the rate of effectiveness of transfer of technology from the nonprofit sector to the industrial sectors; and 3) by increasing the likelihood that spillovers from nonprofit research are captured within the region. |
| Florida, Richard and Wesley M. Cohen (1999). Engine or Infrastructure? The Role in Economic Development. In Lewis M. Branscomb, Fumio Kodama, and Richard Florida (Eds.), University-Industry Linkages in Japan and the United States. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. | Florida and Cohen lay out the underpinnings of a better conceptual understanding or theory of the university’s role in knowledge-based capitalism. The authors also consider the tensions that the university’s new role is generating and reconsider the notion of the university as an ‘engine’ of economic development. The authors stress the importance of moving away from a limited concept of the university as an engine of economic development and to begin to view the university as a complicated institutional underpinning of regional and national growth. |
|
Rai, Arti K. (2004). The Increasingly Proprietary Nature of Publicly Funded Biomedical Research: Benefits and Threats. In Donald Stein (Ed.), Buying In or Selling Out?: The Commercialization of the American Research University. New Brunswick, NH: Rutgers University Press.
| Rai reviews how the American legal system encourages academics working in biotechnology to attempt to patent their work. She also addresses the financial impact of product licensing on university activities and the role that such licensing plays in restricting the flow of communication essential to the conduct of good science. Rai considers whether or not exclusive patenting is financially beneficial or whether models other than exclusive patenting may be more effective in promoting product development. |
|
Hall, Zach (2004). The Academy and Industry: A View Across the Divide. In Donald Stein (Ed.), Buying In or Selling Out?: The Commercialization of the American Research University. New Brunswick, NH: Rutgers University Press.
| Hall suggests that academic institutions and private companies need each other and can provide highly symbiotic and beneficial working environments benefiting society at large. Halls claims that the key to success in these relationships is for both parties to recognize that they may have different needs, agendas, and missions. As long as the distinctions are preserved and recognized, Halls sees no conflicts, arguing that both sides succeed in advancing the research necessary to remain competitive at both the intellectual and economic levels. |
| Gray, Paul E. (1994). Technology Transfer at MIT. In Norman E. Bowie, University-Business Partnerships: An Assessment. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. | Gray describes the various forms of university-business partnerships at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and then describes some of the positive outcomes of such partnerships. He highlights potential conflicts of interest should a faculty member or university hold equity in a firm that is the result of such partnerships, and describes MIT’s efforts to manage these potential conflicts. Overall, Gray believes that MIT policies foster practical applications of new technologies and in turn contribute to U.S. competitiveness in global markets. |
| Noble, David (1994). Technology Transfer at MIT: A Critical View. In Norman E. Bowie, University-Business Partnerships: An Assessment. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. | Noble believes that university-business partnerships provide too great an opportunity for private gain at public expense to go unregulated. Noble takes to task the MIT Industrial Liaison Program for primarily benefiting multinationals, rather than American businesses. Noble advocates for the extension of the Whistleblower Protection Act to university personnel participating in federally funded research to curb ‘unregulated academic conflicts of interest’. |
| Schneiderman (1994). Technology Transfer in Biotech. In Norman E. Bowie, University-Business Partnerships: An Assessment. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. | Schneiderman discusses Monsanto Company ‘discovery research’ partnerships with universities (in contrast to drug development research). He believes that university-business partnerships are essential to retain U.S. economic competitiveness. Rather than limiting the access of foreign companies to American research universities, Schneiderman advocates for equal access of American scientists, engineers and companies to foreign research and engineering centers. |
| Brodhead, Richard H. (2004). The Good of This Place: Values and Challenges in College Education. New Haven: Yale University Press. | This book is a collection of writings produced while Brodhead was Dean of Yale College. The first section focuses how undergraduates can get the most from their undergraduate education. Later sections focus on familiar challenges of the modern university – ranging from free speech to diversity issues to questions of constructing a coherent curriculum. |
| Assié-Lumumba, N’Dri Thérèse (2000). Educational and Economic Reforms, Gender Equity, and Access to Schooling in Africa. Comparative Sociology, 41(1), 89-120. | This paper investigates the relationship between economic reforms, particularly the World Bank’s Structural Adjustment Programs (SAPS), and educational policies with regard to gender equity in access to schooling in Africa. Using qualitative, historical, and quantitative methods based on data from UNESCO and African Development Bank, it analyzes the impact of economic factors, specifically gross domestic investment, public expenditure on education as a percentage of gross national product, public expenditure on education as a percentage of government expenditure, and government deficit/surplus as a percentage of GDP at current prices, on women’s access to higher education. |
|
Folson, Rose B. (2006). Economic Restructuring and Education in Ghana. In Ali Abdi, Korbla Puplampu and George Sefa Dei (Eds.), African Education and Globalization: Critical Perspectives. New York: Lexington Books, 135-150.
| In this chapter, Folson explores the role of education in enhancing processes of economic and social development in Ghana. Additionally, she examines how theories of human capital and equity apply to Ghana as well as how it is positioned in the global economy. She concludes that while currently in Ghana there is a consensus among policy makers and educational donor agencies that basic education and the humanities are essential for national development, the potential of higher education to promote development is being realized only marginally. |
|
Puplampu, Korbla P. (2005). National "Development" and African Universities: A Theoretical and Sociopolitical Analysis. In Ali Abdi and Ailie Cleghorn (Eds.), Issues in African Education: Sociological Perspectives. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 42-64.
| Institutions of higher education, specifically universities and colleges, have been at the center of attention in the task of national development. In this chapter, the literature on the contemporary state of African universities is briefly examined and situated in a broader global context. Puplampu offers a theoretical analysis of the changing conditions of academic laborers in the midst of the restructuring and differentiation of universities. |
| Kwesiga, Joy (2002). Women's Access to Higher Education in Africa Uganda's Experience. Oxford, African Books Collective. | Kwesiga addresses the gender divide in access to higher education within Uganda. She examines theories of girls' education, human capital, gender inequality and gender development, from an African perspective and its institutions to debates often constructed and conducted in the West. Whilst commending the work of women's movements and NGO's in furthering the educational cause, it criticizes fashionable neo-liberal economic/educational policies which are diverting researchers not institutions, thus diminishing local universities and women. Kwesiga also presents the results of a survey of female undergraduates at the University of Makerere, which give rise to discussions about family, societal, and institutional influences on women's access to higher education. |
|
Teferra, Damtew and Philip G. Altbach (2003). Trends and Perspectives in African Higher Education. In Damtew Teferra and Philip Altbach (Eds.), African Higher Education: An International Reference Handbook, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 3-14.
| This introductory chapter to the authors' edited volume generally discusses the challenges facing African higher education in the new millennium. Universities are recognized as keys to development and modernization, and demand for access has grown tremendously. Nevertheless, African universities remain underfunded and the least developed region in terms of higher education. The authors are not optimistic about the future of African universities, given the difficult circumstances under which they operate. This chapter explores issues of access, funding, gender, academic freedom, and the brain drain. |
| Sherman, Mary Antoinette Brown (1990). The University in Modern Africa. The Journal of Higher Education, 61(4), 363-386. | According to Sherman, the African university is critical to the development of the country and will contribute to the solution of Africa's problems. A history of the development of higher education in Africa is given. |
| Pillay, Punday (2004). The South African Experience with Developing and Implementing a Funding Formula for the Tertiary Education System. Journal of Higher Education in Africa, 2(3), 19-36. | The funding framework developed in South Africa for institutions of higher education during the apartheid era raises serious concerns related to equity and efficiency. The new funding framework proposed in the government’s 1997 White Paper re-conceptualises the relationship between institutional costs and government expenditures. Institutions now receive (a) block funds (research funds, teaching funds determined by student numbers and outputs, and institutional funds for redress purposes), and (b) earmarked funds for specific purposes (e.g., student financial aid and research development). This framework has important implications for equity and efficiency including predictability; the recognition of a hard budget constraint; promoting institutional autonomy and equity; rewards for research outputs; rewards for graduate outputs that supply the country’s human development needs; and enhanced equity through capacity building, research development, and foundation programs. |
| Ramphele, Mamphela. (2004). The University as an Actor in Development: New Perspectives and Demands. Journal of Higher Education in Africa, 2 (1), 15-34. | Ramphele addresses the obstacles hampering African universities from playing their needed role in national development, particularly challenges stemming from the unfinished agenda of national reforms and emergence of globalization. This work examines pervading issues of higher education within the context of HIV/AIDS pandemic and massive brain drain. Using OECD countries for comparison, it presents demographic, migration, health, and educational analysis for Africa. The paper underscores the presence of substantial differences between countries with respect to incomes, education systems, political institutions, and, in a more dynamic sense, economic performance over time. It also argues that we are undergoing an integration process (through globalization) which is critically based on knowledge. It warns that developing countries are falling behind industrialized ones in terms of low enrollments, low quality of education output, and low retention of qualified persons. |
|
Nafukho, Fredrick Muyia (2004). The Market Model of Financing State Universities in Kenya: Some Innovative Lessons. In Paul Zeleza and Adebayo Olukoshi (Eds.), African Universities in the Twenty-First Century, vol. 1. South Africa: UNISA Press, 126-139.
| Nafukho examines Kenyan higher education and describes the shift to a market model occurring in Kenyan state universities. He argues that education is the most durable investment for African development and points to six universities in Kenya who have successfully initiated entrepreneurial projects aimed at solving declining state budgetary allocations. |
| Ntshoe, Isaac M. (2003). The Political Economy of Access and Equitable Allocation of Resources to Higher Education. International Journal of Educational Development, 23(4), 381-398. | Accelerated expansion of and increased access to higher education (HE) have been widely supported as a response to the social, political and economic imperatives in many countries. Ntshoe examines demands to accelerate expansion of and increase access to higher education for blacks and to make the higher education sector competitive, cost-effective and efficient in the changing conditions in post-apartheid South Africa. It argues that the increased access to higher education have not significantly improved the achievement of social equity, social justice and social development because of the external influence of global competitiveness. It argues further that the current policy of institutional mergers and incorporations is driven by demands to make the higher education sector efficient and does not seem to sufficiently address historical inequities in higher education. |
|
Moja, Teboho (2004). Policy Responses to Global Transformation by African Higher Education Systems. In Paul Zeleza and Adebayo Olukoshi (Eds.), African Universities in the Twenty-First Century, vol. 1. South Africa: UNISA Press, 21-41.
| Moja explores the effect of global restructuring on African higher education. Globalization, which has been almost uniformly negative for Africa, has sparked debate about the future role of higher education in African society. Moja describes the new policies and approaches that African universities are adopting. As new policies arise, African scholars express concerns with the lack of active participation in the new economic development strategies. |
| Kraak, Andre (2001). Equity, Development, and New Knowledge Production: An Overview of the New Higher Education Policy Environment in Post-Apartheid South Africa. Equity and Excellence in Education, 34(3), 15-25. | Kraak traces the influence of a body of international literature on the development of post-apartheid policies in South African higher education and training (HET), focusing on the emergence of a new mode of knowledge production and its impact on HET. Questions of equity and economic development (and their interrelationship) are key themes implicit in the analysis. |
|
Gravenir, Frederick Q. (2004). The Expansion of University Programmes and Problems of Under- and Over-Supply of Skilled Personnel in Kenya: An Overview. In Paul Zeleza and Adebayo Olukoshi (Eds.), African Universities in the Twenty-First Century, vol. 2. South Africa: UNISA Press, 534-543.
| Since Kenyan independence in 1963, the higher education sector has expanded rapidly. Despite this expansion, as a developing country, Kenya has not been able to produce skilled personnel in the quantity and quality to develop its economy. Gravenir explores the issue of higher education's inability to produce the type of workforce needed for Kenya to develop. |
|
Ilon, Lynn (2003). Foreign Aid Financing of Higher Education in Africa. In Damtew Teferra and Philip Altbach (Eds.), African Higher Education: An International Reference Handbook. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 61-72.
| Ilon examines the role of foreign aid in Africa higher education. This aid waxes and wanes over the years as it is linked to development ideology, the perceived role of education in that ideology, and the geopolitical position of Africa. Ilon argues that to understand the changes in foreign aid one must understand the changing character and role of development ideology in Africa. |
| Butare, Albert (2004). Income-Generating Activities in Higher Education: The Case of Kigali Institute of Science, Technology and Management (KIST) Journal of Higher Education in Africa 2(3), 37-54. | Butare investigates the income-generating activities at The Kigali Institute of Science, Technology and Management (KIST), Rwanda’s first higher education institution of technology, which has taken lead in entrepreneurial activities. From its inception, it has combined conventional teaching with technology transfer initiatives. Particularly successful have been projects involving renewable energies, waste-water management and food-processing. Products developed have included, for example, low-cost hand- and foot-powered water pumps, rainwater-harvesting systems, a crop dryer that uses either sunshine or biomass (such as rice husks, sawdust or firewood), etc. Another income source is providing paid part-time studies for working adults. |
| Zweig, David, Changgui Chen, and Stanley Rosen (2004). Globalization and Transnational Human Capital: Overseas and Returnee Scholars to China. The China Quarterly, 179, 735-757. | As societies internationalize, the demand for, and the value of, various goods and services increase. Individuals who possess new ideas, technologies and information that abets globalization become imbued with “transnational human capital,” making them more valuable to these societies. The authors look at this issue from five perspectives. First, they show that China's education and employment system is now highly internationalized. Secondly, since even Chinese scholars sent by the government rely heavily on foreign funds to complete their studies, China is benefiting from foreign capital invested in the cohort of returnees. Thirdly, they show that foreign PhDs are worth more than domestic PhDs in terms of perception, technology transfer, and in their ability to bring benefits to their universities. Finally, returnees in high tech zones, compared to people in the zones who had not been overseas, were more likely to be importing technology and capital, to feel that their skills were in great demand within society, and to be using that technology to target the domestic market. |
|
Bat-Erdene, Regsurengiin, Surengiin Davaa, and John L. Yeager (1999). The National University of Mongolia: The Winds of Change. In Paula Sabloff (Ed.), Higher Education in the Post-Communist World: Case Studies of Eight Countries. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc., 189-236.
| The National University of Mongolia, currently one of several institutions of higher education located in Mongolia, represents an interesting example of how one institution is developing and changing as part of a nation experiencing rapid and severe social and economic changes. To understand the actions of the National University, Bat-Erdene examines the larger historical, social, and political context of Mongolia in general as well as the higher education sector in particular. |
| Cheng, Joseph Y. S. (1995). Higher Education in Hong Kong — The Approach to 1997 and the China Factor. Higher Education, 30(3), 257 - 271. | Hong Kong has two major economic assets: its geographical location and labor force. Shortage of educated manpower has created a bottleneck hampering economic growth. Substantial emigration flows relating to 1997 is also a problem. The development of higher education and infrastructure as a means to ensure sustainable economic growth are investigated in this article. |
| Collins, Steven and Hikoji Wakoh (2000). Universities and Technology Transfer in Japan: Recent Reforms in Historical Perspective. The Journal of Technology Transfer, 25(2), 213 - 222, | The Japanese government has embarked on a series of reforms aimed at stimulating technology transfer from universities to industry. As a result, technology licensing offices are springing up at many national universities and advocates hope that these reforms will increase the level of university patenting and licensing. Based on the technology licensing process in the United States, such changes face serious historical and institutional barriers. Academic researchers, especially in engineering and physical science, have a long record of collaborative research with industry. Decisions about patenting, however, were usually left to the corporate partner; universities rarely filed for patents under their own name, nor have they, until recently, encouraged or assisted faculty researchers in doing so. Consequently, the authors argue that current reforms, by going against the grain of past practices, will take time to achieve the hoped for results. |
| Jayaweera, Swarna (1997). Higher Education and the Economic and Social Empowerment of Women - The Asian Experience. Compare: A Journal of Comparative Education, 27(3), 245-261. | Jayaweera examines the degree of socioeconomic empowerment of Asian women due to higher education (HE). Examples illustrate different cultural contexts and stages in development. Colonial administrations established the first modern educational institutions which trained Western-oriented elites in Western and gender values. Uneven development led to increased socioeconomic differences and disparities by region, ethnicity, religion, and gender. The international focus on women's rights has helped with promotion of education for gender equity. But, the international economic climate has led to adverse outcomes for education. Educational mobility is restricted by exclusion or lack of access to HE. Most of the 15 countries with strong educational systems have minimal gender disparities in primary and secondary education, but even Japan has gender disparities in HE. In nine South Asian countries, most girls are disadvantaged from birth through the school years. Only India and the Philippines have explicit, conscious policies to promote gender equity. |
| Jayaweera, Swarna (1997). Women, Education and Empowerment in Asia. Gender and Education, 9(4), 411-424. | Education is widely perceived as an indicator of the status of women and even more importantly, as an agent for the empowerment of women. Jayaweera examines the relationship between education and several facets of empowerment, using the macro statistics on countries in Asia presented in the United Nations Human Development Report, 1995, which attempts to compute country specific 'Gender Empowerment Measures', as well as data from qualitative studies in selected representative countries. The study concludes that there is no positive linear relationship between education and the economic, social and political empowerment of women, as a consequence of the interface of gender ideologies and social and economic structural constraints. It further examines factors that surface from within education structures and content and from social and economic structures and gender relations within the family that constrain the role of education as an agent for the empowerment of women. |
|
Kwong, Julia (2003). Women's Education in China's New Socialist Market Economy. In Ka-Ho Mok (Ed.), Centralization and Decentralization: Educational Reforms and Changing Governance in Chinese Societies. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishing, 99-113.
| Kwong examines how social changes have affected women's education in China. More specifically, she explores how changes in educational policies, society's view of women's roles, and the employment situation have affected the educational opportunities offered to women. In the Maoist period, the contribution of women in development was valued; the state adopted special measures to prevent the traditional discrimination against women, provide them equal educational opportunities, and raise their social status. In the reform era, the state did not renege on these promises, but rather shifted its focus so as to develop the stronger rather than the weaker sectors while simultaneously assuming a more passive role in the distribution of national resources. This re-orientation in state priorities under market socialism has, no doubt, affected the education of women. |
| Kuroda, Kazuo and Hossain Md. Shanawez (2003). Strategies for Promoting Virtual Higher Education: General Considerations on Africa and Asia. African and Asian Studies, 2(4), 565 - 575. | Education in general, and specifically higher education, plays an important role in the development process of all nations. Institutions of higher education have an important responsibility to support knowledge-driven economic growth strategies. The authors investigate how the application of technology — with close attention to quality — can help higher education to find a way through the crisis of access, prohibitive cost, and lack of flexibility that we find all over the developing world. By addressing various issues related to planning, implementation, and quality, virtual education can provide immense opportunity to reduce the North-South knowledge gap and also to promote the development of the developing world. The authors review various issues related to promotion and quality control in virtual higher education and address possible strategies with general considerations of Africa and Asia. |
| Kitamura, Kazuyuki (1997). Policy Issue in Japanese Higher Education. Higher Education, 34(2), 141 - 150. | Kitamura discusses the following elements of the Japanese higher education reform movement: de-regulation and moves towards self-regulation; accountability; higher education as an economic resource; and internationalization. Some further challenges are reviewed, notably the impact of future demographic change when the relevant age cohorts decrease. This is all the more significant since so much of the system relies on the private sector which is in turn dependent on fee-income. Kitamura also draws attention to evidence that Japanese industry is changing its expectations of what higher education should be providing for its students. |
| Morris, Paul (1996) Asia's Four Little Tigers: A Comparison of the Role of Education in Their Development, Comparative Education, 32(1), 95-110. | The economic success of some of the countries within the East Asian region has generated a range of studies which have attempted to identify the sources of that growth. One strand within these analyses has focused on the critical role of schooling in the accumulation of human capital. Morris examines the role which education has played in the rapid development of the four 'Asian Tigers'; namely: Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea and Singapore. It is argued that whilst patterns of educational provision displayed some common features there were also significant differences in other areas such as the role of the state, sources of educational funding, the role of technical education and of the school curriculum. |
| Ashton, David, Francis Green, Johnny Sung, Donna James (2002). The Evolution of Education and Training Strategies in Singapore, Taiwan and South Korea: A Development Model of Skill Formation. Journal of Education and Work, 15(1), 5-30. | The authors challenge the conventional explanation of the role of the state in skill formation in the high performing Asian economies as advocated by World Bank economists. They do this through an examination of the institutions which supported beneficial strategic state intervention in the process of skill formation in Singapore, Taiwan and South Korea. These enabled governments to produce a pace of skill formation so high that it achieved within the space of one generation something that took the advanced industrial countries three generations to achieve. Our research has identified a set of government strategies and associated institutional structures in the field of education and training in these economies which, it is argued, played a crucial role in ensuring that economic growth could proceed without employers experiencing severe skill shortages. |
| Law, Wing-Wah (1996). Fortress State, Cultural Continuities and Economic Change: Higher Education in Mainland China and Taiwan. Comparative Education, 32(3), 377 - 394. | Since 1949, the higher education systems in mainland China and Taiwan have been developed in disparate geopolitical and social contexts, but have faced similar dilemmas between economic and cultural tasks. The dilemma has lasted in China for more than two centuries and nowadays can also be located in many developing industrializing countries. Law offers the concept of 'fortress state' to explain how between 1949 and 1995 these two countries were affected by both domestic and international factors. In particular, the role of higher education as an agent of both political socialization and economic modernization is analyzed in the context of the transformations in the two contemporary Chinese societies. Law also examines how cultural traditions, the upholding of a national belief system, nation building and the foreign relations of mainland China and Taiwan help maintain the two-century old tension between economic modernization and the preservation of a cultural and national identity. |
| Mok, Ka-Ho (2006). Education Reform and Education Policy in East Asia. New York: Routledge. | Mok assesses the impact of globalization on the education systems of key East Asian countries, including China, Hong Kong, Japan, and the "tiger economies" of South Korea, Taiwan and Singapore, examining how the increasingly interdependent economic systems have driven policy changes and education reforms. Mok discusses how policy makers have responded to changes required in educational outcomes in order to equip their societies for new global conditions and explores the impact of new approaches and ideologies related to globalization, such as marketization, privatization, governance changes, managerialism, economic rationalism and neo-liberalism, making comparisons across the region. Based upon in-depth research, fieldwork, literature analysis, policy document analysis and personal reflections of academics serving in the education sector, Mok recounts heated debates about the pros and cons of educational restructuring in East Asia. |
| Singh, Jasbir Sarjit (1991). Higher Education and Development: The Experience of Four Newly Industrializing Countries in Asia. Prospects, 21(3), 386-400. | Singh reviews developments in higher education in four Newly Industrialized Countries (NICs) in east Asia, contending that improvements have resulted from policies that strengthen and develop scientific and technological capacity. He stresses the link between effective higher education and economic well-being. |
|
Rui, Yang (2003). Progress and Paradoxes: New Developments in China's Higher Education. In Ka-Ho Mok (Ed.), Centralization and Decentralization: Educational Reforms and Changing Governance in Chinese Societies. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishing, 173-200.
| Rui illustrates how the governance of Chinese higher education has been significantly affected by the "economic ideology of education," while the role of the government, particularly the central state, as a regulator and overall service coordinator, has been strengthened rather than weakened under the policy of decentralization. |
|
Phillips, Matthew W. and Charles W. Stahl (2001). International Trade in Higher Education Services in the Asia Pacific Region: Trends and Issues. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 10(2), 273-301.
| The expansion of trade and investment in the global economy since the 1980s has been accompanied by an associated growth in the international trade in education services, particularly higher education. The authors provide a detailed analysis of the expansion of higher educational mobility, measured by the burgeoning numbers of tertiary students going abroad to study. In particular, the authors investigate the increasing mobility of students from the Asia Pacific region undertaking study in Western Europe, North America and Australia. The paper argues that increasing international trade in education services in the Asia Pacific region reflects the strategic importance of these services to develop and maintain the long-term economic and social viability of these nations. |
| Bound, John and Sarah Turner (2006). Cohort Crowding: How Resources Affect Collegiate Attainment. NBER Working Paper No. 12424. Cambridge, MA: NBER. | Using data covering the last half of the twentieth century, Bound and Turner find strong evidence that large college cohorts within the United States have relatively low undergraduate degree attainment, reflecting less than perfect elasticity of supply in the higher education market. That large cohorts receive lower public subsidies per student in higher education explains this result, indicating that resources have large effects on degree production. The results suggest that reduced resources per student following from rising cohort size and lower state expenditures are likely to have significant negative effects on the supply of colleged-educated workers entering the labor market. |